Saturday, May 18, 2013

2013 NFL ROOKIE QUARTERBACK RANKINGS



bigcatcountry.com
Tyler Wilson has a chance to outperform the competition in 2013


Josh Inglis
Saturday May 18, 2018

The 2013 QB draft class is a sad group of individuals. It’s so sad that Jacksonville Jaguars quarterback coach Frank Scelfo has said that Blaine Gabbert would be the first quarterback chosen if he were in the draft this year.

There might not be a week one starter in the whole lot.  If you expected to find your franchise quarterback in this year’s group then you didn’t do your homework.

Just because there is no top end talent like RG3 or Andrew Luck, doesn’t mean that there aren’t players on this list that can’t improve your fake teams.  There might even be one or two in the group that make a significant fantasy impact down the road.  So without further adieu I present my 2013 QB Rookie Rankings.

*the numbers inside the parenthesis represent the players current ADP (Average Draft Position)
(rookie draft ADP/ Dynasty Start Up ADP/ Redraft ADP)


Quarterbacks

TIER 1
 
1. EJ Manuel BUF (20/31/174)

There’s a lot to like about EJ in Buffalo. He has a new coach who can tailor an offensive system around the strengths of his players (hello option?), the support of his GM to start in week 1, CJ spiller, 3 time 1000 yard receiver Stevie Johnson and a plethora of young receiving talent that includes USC standout Robert Woods. Before we get ahead of ourselves let’s remember that this man is a serious project and might be watching Kevin Kolb run the offense come September.  New coach Doug Marrone has already pointed out that Manuel needs to work on his footwork and mechanics.  We haven’t even seen him in a collapsing pocket yet.

On the plus side I like the fact that he is starting to build chemistry with his fellow rookie receivers Woods, Goodwin and Rogers at rookie camp.  This receiving core could surprise people this year and looking ahead, Manuel might have the ability to throw to two 1000 yard receivers in the same year.

He was ranked the 6th quarterback by Scouts Inc before the draft. The Bills cited his deep accuracy (49.2 percent of passes over 20 yards in 2012) and his ability to make plays with his arm while on the run (55.8 percent completion while on the move in 2013) as reasons for taking the former Seminole with the 16th overall pick. They believe that he can be their franchise quarterback. 

I like him as a QB 3 with great upside or a low end QB 2 in dynasty formats and will let someone else take him in a redraft.  This is not 2012 people. Don’t over value new quarterbacks because of the ridiculousness that happened last year (RG3, Luck, Wilson and Tannehill).

If he falls to you late in your rookie draft take a shot on him and maybe this year or next year, you can swap him for a higher pick or a better starter. I like him in the third round of a rookie draft.

2. Geno Smith NYJ (22/34/180)

On paper Smith looks like a bargain at 39th overall.

2012 stats
71.2 completion percentage,
42:6 TD:INT ratio
Led the nation in passing TDs with 42
Was sacked only 19 times in 13 games

So why wasn’t Geno selected earlier? Because apparently, “he fails to realize he doesn’t know everything”

When I think of Geno I think of Willie Beaman from Any Given Sunday. 

My name is Geno…………..Smith ya
I keep the ladies ………in bliss ya
And all my fans……………big ups ya
You gunna defeat me?...........Mark Sanchez

With reports out that describe Smith as being a “Diva”, “a spoiled pampered brat” and having trouble “in working through adversity” I say good luck to you in New York.  This one could end badly. How Tim Tebow made it out of New York alive is beyond me. That media is relentless.

It’s as simple as winning though.  If Mark Sanchez is released and the starting gig is handed to Geno, no one is going to care about his attitude if he is winning ball games. He will have every chance to show he deserved to be the 2nd quarterback taken in the draft. 

He has the most talent out of the 2013 QB class and could put up decent fantasy production, but looking at his supporting cast (Ivory, Holmes, Hill, Kerley) his upside is limited.  He will not be a top 10 quarterback this year and maybe never.  Also, like Manuel, feel free to draft him with a future plan to turn him into something more than you originally invested.


TIER 2

3.  Tyler Wilson OAK (46/67/230)

This is one of my favorite quarterbacks in the draft.  I’m more in love with his opportunity and toughness than his above average skill set.  Coaches love tough quarterbacks and Wilson was the toughest in the draft.  If you can’t stand in the pocket or move around and step up, you are not going to make it in the NFL (hello Blaine Gabbert). Reports are out that he has looked good at minicamp. Wilson has a chance to unseat Matt Flynn and start in week 1. 

Anytime you hear the word gunslinger associated with a quarterback, there are obvious fantasy rewards to be had. Wilson may never be a top 8 QB, but he could surprise many this year and produce fantasy numbers similar to Ben Roethlisberger or Carson Palmer in 2012.  He has enough weapons in Oak to put up 25 TD seasons and maybe go for 3800 plus yards. It may not happen this year, but sometime in the near future is a possibility. Keep an eye on Tyler Wilson during OTAs and the preseason.

4.  Zac Dysert DEN (58/181/NA)

A top 3 quarterback in some circles, Dysert fell all the way to the 234th pick in this year’s draft. The former ReHawk has a big arm and stands firm in the pocket. He could push for number 2 duties behind Peyton Manning if he can pass second year man Brock Osweiler (also someone to watch). The backup spot behind an aging and brittle quarterback and on a team as loaded offensively as the Broncos are exciting tangibles.  Dysert is a good dynasty draft pick because he realistically has a chance to lead a top 3 offense.  Manning owners need to invest and also people with quarterback youth and depth problems should jump on board.  It may take a year or two but the return on Dysert could be very profitable.

5.  Mike Glennon TB (54/73/NA)

Glennon stands at 6’7’’and has a powerful arm that is also accurate.  Ron Jaworski says he is “built like an oak tree”.  It’s also no secret that Tampa Bay is not very high on Josh Freeman and Dan Orlovsky (both only have one year left on their contracts). It’s somewhat possible that Glennon could be starting for the Bucs in 2014. 

Doug Martin, Vincent Jackson and Mike Williams give the 73rd overall pick lots of potent weapons to choose from.  The man who filled Russell Wilson’s shoes at North Carolina State is worth holding onto for a year because he might be starting in week 1 in 2014.  Glennon is a smart pick late in rookie drafts and dynasty start up drafts and has a very similar situation to Zach Dysert in Denver.  Use the wait and see approach here as the return could be exponential. Think Russell Wilson.

6.  Matt Barkley PHI (37/52/209)

When NFL guru Greg Cosell says that Mark Sanchez was a better prospect coming out of USC than Barkley, immediately his career might be in trouble.  Barkley has great grades on accuracy, intelligence and leadership but has a girl’s arm when it comes to throwing deep balls or passes outside the numbers. Guys who can’t throw deep in the NFL usually don’t project well statistically but can still win ball games.  Just ask Andy Dalton. Luckily for him however, Chip Kelly’s offense calls for short quick accurate passes and with Michael Vick holding the ball for too long, the USC grad might get a shot in the new system down the road. 

This guy is not going to lead you to any fantasy championships but you might be able to trade him to a Michael Vick owner.

TIER 3
 
7.  Ryan Nassib NYG (56/89/208)

“Borderline starting talent”, comparisons to Andy Dalton and mediocre arm strength mean one thing in the fantasy world, irrelevance. If his own College coach didn’t want to take him neither should you.  If you feel that Eli Manning needs a hand cuff, by all means take the man.  I prefer Wilson.

8.  Tyler Bray KCC (65/79/NA)

Undrafted due to maturity problems, Bray projects as a developmental third quarterback on the Chiefs.  Bray even went undrafted in the Bray Family Football Dynasty League.

This quarterback draft class is getting depressing and we are still not at the bottom.

9.  Landry Jones PIT (69/80/NA)

Could see time if Ben goes down but does not have the talent to push for the starting position.  He is only a Big Ben hand cuff at best. Not even tradable and shouldn’t be drafted even in 53 man roster leagues.

TIER 4
 
10.  Matt Scott JAC(72/67/NA)

Undrafted in the NFL and should be undrafted in all formats of Fantasy Football, unless you are trying to assemble the entire Jaguars offense.  If that’s the case, don’t forget to take back up FB and former ATL no. 3 quarterback Will Ta’ufo’ou.



Josh Inglis is on the wrong side of 30. He wishes he was 6 inches taller and had hair he could comb.  He writes and operates backtobacksports.com. He currently lives in Taiwan.

0 comments:

Post a Comment